Position: We will seek dialogue

Position │ "We will seek dialogue" - Politics, science and the people in the regions that come into question for a final repository site must negotiate a result together.

by Oliver Heidbach, Michael Kühn, Leni Scheck-Wenderoth, and Josef Zens

Nuclear waste is uncanny for us. Nuclear waste scares us. Moreover, enraged demonstrations against reprocessing plants, against CASTOR transports and against final underground storage are part of Germany's cultural heritage. But, as a young researcher from the GFZ casually put it: "The stuff is there - and now it has to be got rid of."

The question is ⁠— where to put it? Where to put radiating toxic waste that will remain life-threatening for hundreds of thousands of years? Neither "politics" nor "science" can answer this question on its own. Rather, politics, science and the inhabitants of regions that come into question for a final repository site must enter into a dialogue and negotiate a solution. To this end, German policy-makers have initiated a procedure that is unique in the world, which is intended to facilitate this process ⁠ and also offers room for readjustments. One thing is clear: the underground is the best of all options. And it is also clear: as a country, we have to face up to our responsibility and cannot simply export the waste. So we have to find a site. The scientific part of the search is an enormous challenge in itself. Geosciences, with their related disciplines of geology, geophysics and geochemistry, have to face the task of identifying a place in the subsurface that guarantees safety for one million years. In this timeframe, which is unimaginable for humans, the landscape in today's Germany will change enormously, just as it has done in the last one million years. This can be deduced from the Earth's recent history and from historical records. It was 12,000 years ago that a volcano erupted in the Eifel — about as strong as Pinatubo. It is not even 300 years ago that an earthquake with a magnitude of 6.4 shook the area around Düren in what is now North Rhine-Westphalia.

This implies that during the next thousand millennia there will be severe tremors, perhaps a volcano will erupt and almost certainly a new ice age will occur. Before that, however, the sea level will continue to rise and flood the islands in the Wadden Sea. The land will still rise where, some 20,000 years ago, a kilometre-thick shield of ice had dented the Earth's crust several hundred metres deep. And plate tectonics is deforming the Earth's crust and will change our landscape, even if slowly.

Such settings need to be combined with our current knowledge of the geological formation and nature of the subsurface. To do this, we need boreholes to directly characterise the rocks and their geochemical properties. We will evaluate geophysical signals to indirectly create a kind of "ultrasound image of the subsurface" and we will use all available data to apply, extend and improve our models. To do this we are cooperating with institutions all over the world in order to research, as precisely as possible, the three host rocks that come into question for Germany: In Germany we already know a lot about rock salt, from Switzerland we have results on mudstone and from Scandinavia we have information on crystalline rock.

It is less than ten years until the planned final decision on a site. Until then, it is the task of the BGE, the Federal Company for Radioactive Waste Disposal, to use the existing data from the State Geological Surveys, the Federal Authorities and the research institutions to narrow down the areas in Germany with a favourable overall geological situation for the construction of a repository and to examine their suitability ever more precisely. At the moment, it is clear that about ,half of our country is not suitable to host a repository site.

During the course of the site selection process, stakeholders need to talk to the regulatory bodies, the scientific community and the public about what methods are used to exclude or select sites and for what reasons. At least from our side, we will actively engage in dialogue with citizens to inform them about the research questions and our answers as well as about the limits of our knowledge. We see ourselves as part of this unique site selection process and as members of the society that generated the nuclear waste.

Published in GFZ-Journal “System Erde” (System Earth) (2021) 2: No nuclear waste repository without geoscience (systemerde.gfz-potsdam.de)

Contact: endlagerforschung@gfz-potsdam.de

Additional News

Portrait Lars Bernard, green background

The Board of Trustees appoints Prof. Lars Bernard to the Scientific Advisory Board of the…

Portrait photo of Harald Schuh, background: green

AGU Award for Harald Schuh

The glass building with flagging "IASS" at Helmholtzstraße 5.

An ideal addition to the Helmholtz Association

SLR Station, Laser

New DFG Research Unit “Clock Metrology: A Novel Approach to TIME in Geodesy” with GFZ…

Niels Hovius portrait

Niels Hovius appointed to the renowned "National Academy of Science and Engineering –…

[Translate to English:] GFZ-Logo

GFZ's position on the Leopoldina paper “Earth System Science”

Kimberella fossile

Feeding strategies of the oldest known animals (Ediacara)

Portraits of the five young researchers

EGU OSPP Awards 2022 to five GFZ researchers

[Translate to English:] Lila Flagge wehend über einem Dachgiebel

Interviews on the occasion of the Purple Light Up 2022

Obituary picture of Dr. Kemâl Erbas.

Obituary Dr. Kemâl Erbas

Two profile photos and in between the logo of BMWK and a symbol image for a text document.

Important signal for the expansion of deep geothermal energy

German map with quality-checked data points, shown as columns

A new heat-flow analysis shows higher values for Germany

P. Martinez-Garzon in a forest next to a giant split rock

Dr. Patricia Martinez-Garzon wins ERC Starting Grant for her project QUAKE-HUNTER

Map of Türkiye with the marked epicentre of the earthquake in the northwestern part of the country

Background on today's earthquake in northwest Türkiye

Topography map of the alps.

What is driving the Alps upwards?

Groupp picture ICDP/IODP Kolloquiums

Joint IODP/ICDP-Colloquium at GFZ

Teachers in lecture hall during lecture

"Extreme Events in the Earth System" - 20th "System Earth" Autumn School

Two young researchers stand in front of trees holding their certificates, next to them stands Ludwig Stroink, who awarded the certificates.

“GFZ Friends” honours Theresa Hennig and Lei Wang with the “Friedrich-Robert-Helmert Prize…

Satellite image of a desert area: Colorful spots show different minerals.

German environmental satellite EnMAP: start into regular operation

On the left, a measuring tower in a low overgrown tundra landscape.

More methane from Siberia in summer

[Translate to English:] Profilfoto mit schwarzem Rahmen von Henning Francke

Obituary: Henning Francke

Group photo with projekt responsible

Making geodata interoperable and suited for curiosity driven research: GEO-INQUIRE project…

Schema Energiebereitstellung durch Geothermie

European Geothermal Congress from 17 to 21 October 2022 in Berlin

Gruppenfoto PAM

International Conference on Polar and Alpine Microbiology

Leni Scheck Wenderoth

“AWG Professional Excellence Award” for Magdalena Scheck-Wenderoth

Ausbildung am GFZ

Berufsausbildung und duales Studium am GFZ

Dr. Ute Weckmann during the opening speech of the workshop

Dr. Ute Weckmann takes over the chairmanship of IAGA Division VI

Anke Neumann aon a boat during a research trip

Dr Anke Neumann is a Senior Humboldt Research Fellow

Earth Model

New DFG priority programme on deep Earth evolution over geologic time

Logo of the Helmholtz Innovation Labs: written words only

Successful interim evaluation of the two Helmholtz Innovation Labs at the GFZ

back to top of main content